What if our schools are preparing children to succeed in a world they are losing the capacity to love? (Field notes from the Columbia Teacher’s College “Awakened Education: Engaging the Spiritual Core” conference.)
Spirit Seekers
What Small Schools Can Teach Us About a Life Worth Living
By Stuart Grauer
What if our schools are preparing children to succeed in a world they are losing the capacity to love?
I was exhausted when I reached Pancho's Kitchen. We were navigating the Colorado River through the Grand Canyon, and after years of building The Grauer School campus, I had reached that point of fatigue where even the things you love begin to feel like boxes on a checklist. I thought I needed rest.
When we finally slipped into a small eddy beside a tiny campsite, surrounded by immense canyon walls, something changed. Darkness came. Stars.
For a little while, I didn't have to accomplish anything, produce anything, or win in the marketplace. I could be there, connected to the river, the other paddlers around me, and a living world way larger than my ambitions or achievements.
—Excerpt from "The Way to Pancho's Kitchen: A Trail Guide for Small School Leaders" by Stuart Grauer
I've spent most of my life wondering how schools might help young people discover that same feeling. Creating space for it, or trying.

Stuart at Columbia University Teachers College, October 24, 2026
Last week, I was invited to present my work on campus spiritual ecology at “Awakened Education: Engaging the Spiritual Core in Whole Person Formation,” a conference at Teachers College, Columbia University. Listening to researchers and educators explore the spiritual lives of young people, I felt I was making another journey down the river to Pancho's Kitchen. A lot of what I heard gave language and research grounding to practices we have cultivated at The Grauer School for decades.
And I thought we weren’t naming an key aspect of all that cultivation—something was left out.
For generations, educational success has been measured primarily through grades, standardized tests, and college admissions. These tell us useful things about what students know and can do, but little about the people they are becoming.
Then came an important breakthrough. Organizations such as Challenge Success and Panorama Education started helping schools examine belonging, engagement, relationships, emotional health, and student well-being. Breakthrough!
At Grauer, our student research results have placed us at the top on important measures of school climate, safety, teacher connection, engagement, and belonging. We also gather rich qualitative evidence through expedition reflections, teacher observations, student self-evaluations, and weekly core-values portfolios.
At last, we've started balancing academic achievement (scholastic flourishing) with values development and well-being (character flourishing). So we're done, right?
Not quite.
Young people are struggling with loneliness, anxiety, relentless comparison, and pressure to construct “successful” (often money-making) identities before discovering who they are. Even students who achieve and belong often struggle to find meaning—to feel like they even matter at school. The data is both rich and alarming.
The research and conversations at Columbia helped advance what I believe is a third dimension of education: spiritual flourishing.

Grauer parents presenting information about their professions at the school's annual Career Fair - October 27, 2026
I don't mean religious instruction, although religious schools have long nurtured spiritual development—that’s actually the origin of schools as we know them. But what I mean is the human capacity for wonder, gratitude, reverence, reflection, purpose, and connection to something larger than oneself (a.k.a. spirituality).
At The Grauer School, we've spent 35 years cultivating these qualities, often without calling them spiritual development.
We take students into wilderness and unfamiliar cultures. We open classrooms to the outdoors. We gather in gratitude circles. We study the local lagoon and its living ecosystems. We invite students to reflect on their relationships, responsibilities, and place in the world.
We have even made love an acceptable word in education.
Consider a class walking down to the lagoon. Students learn biology and collect scientific data. They strengthen relationships with teachers and classmates. But they may also experience awe, humility, reverence, and a sense of belonging to the living world.
These don’t have to be three separate educational programs. They are three dimensions of one experience.
A Prescription
My journey to Columbia Teachers college brought new clarity on these three dimensions. And when I got home, just yesterday, I had an appointment with my integrative medicine cardiologist at Scripps, who happens to be a surfer. I mentioned that it seemed like my stamina seemed a little low lately. All this travel! He studied my mountain of medical tests and offered his prescription:
“You need to surf more days and stay out there longer.”
I repeated it back to him, just to cap this moment: “So my cardiologist is prescribing more surfing!” Like great teachers, doctors like this are healers. It reminded me of years ago when my physician examined me, then took out a prescription pad, when they still had those paper pads, and wrote on it the Chinese symbol: Qi ( 气 ). Look it up.
I love that. All those scientific measurements, and my prescription was more time in the ocean. More movement, more immersion in nature, more of something I love. More Qi.
I think that's what we need to remember about education, right now more than ever as some kids feel like they are drowning. The measurements matter. But so does knowing what makes a human being come alive. Our kids need healers.
So here's what intrigues me, and let me know if it intrigues you: Have schools like ours been cultivating spiritual development all along without fully recognizing or evaluating it as such? Without calling anything “spiritual,” maybe for fear of straying out of our lane?
Small schools are particularly well positioned to explore this question. Their relationships, traditions, expeditions, and close attention to individual students offer opportunities to understand not just what children accomplish, but what moves them, sustains them, and gives their lives meaning. How can a primary or secondary school not have a powerful spiritual dimension?

Grauer 10th Grade students learning about historical revolutions in World History class - October 27, 2026
We don't need to grade a child's spirituality (though I’m positive we could, and I’d sorta like to). But at this discursive time in history, we must ask whether our schools make room for wonder, reflection, inherent worth, and connection—and listen carefully to what students experience:
We and our students are increasingly being told, by national leaders and even by our neighbors, that we live in a world ruled by force and money, and that believing otherwise is naïve, or even for suckers. This is a world view that rears its ugly head up every generation or so and it often is evidence of war brewing and fear growing. I take this view also as evidence of the urgent need for the kind of education I have spent a lifetime advocating. You might call it a political issue, but to me it is an educational issue and, essentially, a spiritual one.
The river and stars at Pancho's Kitchen didn't care about my résumé or who had won anything. And there, I could finally rest. But this experience didn't diminish my desire to make my contribution. It renewed it. I did not need rest nearly so much as I needed to remember the deeper sense of what was worth striving for, and why. And the recent pilgrimage to Teachers College at Columbia University awakened that same conviction: We don't need to lower our aspirations for education. We need to raise them. And far from exhausting us, working on that “higher purpose” is what renews our energy.
We know how to ask what students know. We are learning to ask whether they belong.
Now it is time to ask whether their school and its teachers are helping them discover a world worth loving… and a life they experience as worth living.
Chart by Stuart Grauer:

COMMENT! Click on the "Comments" drop-down box below to share a comment.
SHARE! Click on the social media icons below or copy the link to share this column.


